Bidding Challenge Results Part A

Dealer: West
Vuln: Love All
Scoring: IMPs

  1. spade
  2. heartQ 7 5
  3. diamondA K 9 6 5
  4. clubK Q J 8 6
Green square in centre
West North East South
1diamond Pass 1heart Pass
2club Pass 2spade Pass
???
Hand 3 .... much more contentious. When asked for my bid, I said that I would choose 3club as long as we were in a forcing situation, but Standard Acol will, I suspect, say otherwise. The intention would be show heart support later. Amazingly, expert A agreed - normally he has a repertoire of critical hyperbole reserved especially for my bidding. He also mentioned 4club in passing, which was the favoured bid of expert C. Expert B bid a simple 4heart, and also commented that 3spade was interesting. Indeed. Many modern players reserve bids like 3spade here as "I have a good hand, but I have no clear cut bid". A forcing (so they said!) 3heart was a popular choice of others I polled.
So what did Joe say? .
Previous page Next page
This section is a placeholder for the forum. For the time being it will be a noshow class.